Putting technology before strategy: the cart-before-horse transformation mistake
Working for a technology company, my role is to help customers eager to embrace the latest technology innovations – I love seeing the latest innovations driving value! But my job is also to ensure they succeed, and one of the key things I ask is upfront: how does this meet your business goals? Because as eager as I am to get stuck into the tech solutions, I’ve also seen too many initiatives fail because the technology doesn’t solve a real-world problem or align to the business strategy.
"If the only tool you have is a hammer, you tend to see every problem as a nail." - Abraham Maslow
I was reminded of this just last week when I was approached by a friend who wanted to implement an AI-driven service agent to handle customer queries. They had seen impressive demos and were excited about the potential. On the surface, this seemed like a forward-thinking move—AI chatbots are becoming standard in customer service. However, as we discussed their broader strategy, an interesting contradiction emerged. For the past two years, their primary customer service strategy had focused on reducing the need for customers to contact them at all. They had invested heavily in improving customer data accuracy, product documentation, streamlining processes, and fixing root causes of common issues.
Implementing a sophisticated AI chatbot would have been impressive, but it ran counter to their core strategy. Through further discussion, we discovered more aligned applications for AI technology: enhancing their predictive analytics to anticipate customer problems before they occurred, using AI to analyse patterns in their existing service interactions to identify future improvements, and deploying automated tools to proactively reach out to customers who might be experiencing issues based on their usage patterns.
This alternative focus would still make use of cutting-edge AI technology but was perfectly aligned with their existing service strategy of reducing overall contact volume. This minor course correction could mean the difference between a costly distraction and a strategic enhancement.
Why Strategy Must Come Before Technology
When we fall in love with a technological solution first, we start looking for problems it can solve, rather than finding the right solutions for our actual business problems.
Unless you’re a technology company then technology should rarely be the driver of transformation; it should be the enabler. Without clear strategic alignment, technology initiatives often lead to:
Wasted resources: Investing in solutions that don't address core business needs
Change fatigue: Implementing new systems that disrupt workflows without delivering meaningful improvements
Fragmented experiences: Creating inconsistent customer or employee experiences due to disconnected technology implementations
Reduced ROI: Failing to realize the promised benefits because the technology doesn't solve actual business problems
I've seen organizations implement advanced analytics platforms without clear data strategies, adopt cloud infrastructure without consideration for their operating model, and deploy automation solutions that employees simply work around rather than with.
Signs You're Putting Technology Before Strategy
So how can you tell if you're at risk of this common transformation mistake? Watch for these warning signs:
The solution preceded the problem: If conversations begin with "we need to implement [technology]" rather than "we need to solve [business problem]," you're likely technology-led rather than strategy-led.
Buzzword-driven initiatives: When project justifications rely heavily on industry buzzwords (think AI, blockchain, metaverse!) rather than clear business outcomes, beware.
No clear metrics for success: If you can't articulate exactly how the technology will impact key business metrics, there's likely no strategic alignment.
Technology team isolation: When technology teams lead transformation efforts with minimal input from business stakeholders, strategic disconnects are almost guaranteed.
FOMO-based decisions: If the primary driver is fear of missing out or keeping up with competitors, rather than addressing specific business needs, you're likely making a technology-first mistake.
How to Avoid This Common Trap
1. Start with Your Business Strategy
Before considering any technology solution, clearly articulate:
What are your organization's strategic priorities?
What specific business outcomes are you trying to achieve?
What pain points or opportunities are you addressing?
How will success be measured?
At one retailer I worked with, they initially wanted to implement an advanced inventory management system. However, when we first revisited their business strategy—which focused on customer experience and personalization—we discovered that a customer data platform would deliver far more strategic value, even though it was less technologically impressive.
2. Map Technology to Strategy Explicitly
Create a clear, explicit mapping between your business strategy and proposed technology initiatives. For each technology investment, document:
Which specific strategic objective it supports
How it will contribute to business outcomes
What dependencies exist for realizing benefits
This mapping should be straightforward and compelling. If you struggle to make these connections, you're likely dealing with a solution in search of a problem.
3. Establish Business-Centric Governance
Put business leaders in the driver's seat of technology decisions. While IT and technology teams provide expertise on what's possible, business stakeholders should determine what's valuable. Create governance structures that:
Require business sponsorship for all technology initiatives
Measure success in business terms, not technical deliverables
Include continuous alignment checks throughout implementation
Empower business stakeholders to course-correct when needed
4. Focus on Business Capabilities, Not Technologies
Instead of thinking about specific technologies, focus on the business capabilities you need to develop. This subtle shift changes the conversation from "we need cloud computing" to "we need the ability to scale operations quickly in new markets."
By focusing on capabilities, you stay cantered on what the business needs to accomplish rather than how it will be accomplished technically.
5. Prioritize Business-Led Pilots
When testing new technologies, ensure pilots are:
Designed to test business hypotheses, not just technical feasibility
Measured against business outcomes
Led by business stakeholders with technology support
Focused on learning, not just implementation
One manufacturing client avoided a costly mistake by running a small-scale pilot of a proposed IoT solution. The pilot revealed that while the technology worked perfectly, the organization lacked the operational processes to act on the data it generated, making the full implementation pointless until those processes were developed.
Win with technology as a strategic enabler
Technology transformation is most powerful when it's in service of clear business strategy. By ensuring your technology initiatives directly support your strategic objectives, you avoid the costly mistake of implementing solutions that don't address real business needs.
Remember that technology itself rarely creates sustainable competitive advantage—it's how technology enables your unique strategy that matters. The most successful transformations occur when technology and strategy work in harmony, with each reinforcing and strengthening the other.
As you embark on your next technology initiative, ask yourself: "Does this technology enable our strategy, or are we adapting our strategy to fit the technology?" The answer will tell you whether you're on the path to transformation success or heading toward a costly distraction.
Until next Friday, keep failing forward!
Failing Forward is a weekly newsletter exploring the lessons we can learn from failure. Subscribe to get insights and actionable strategies to drive meaningful change.
